Log in
MAIL US
inquiry@maximsguitarworkshop.com
CALL US :
+61432184511
Buying a second hand guitar: a used Yamaha acoustic guitar ready for inspection

Buying a Second Hand Guitar in Australia: Checklist

A good used guitar can be the best value in music. It can also be a warped neck, a cracked headstock or a seller who disappears with your money. This guide to buying a second hand guitar in Australia is built around one question you have to answer standing in a stranger’s lounge room: is this a simple fix, or do I walk away? In our 20 years of teaching, we have seen students bring in brilliant bargains and a few heartbreakers, and the difference was rarely luck. It was knowing what to check, what it costs to fix, and when to say no thanks.

Quick answer

Before you pay, check who is selling, because the ACCC says most consumer guarantees do not apply to private sales, while business sellers must meet them even for second hand goods. Inspect in person: neck, frets, bridge and top, electronics, tuners and serial number. Old strings, high action that adjusts out and scratchy pots are simple fixes. A truss rod that will not turn, a twisted neck or a headstock break are walk away problems. Follow Scamwatch: never pay before you inspect, and check the payee name matches the seller.

Buying a second hand guitar in Australia (what to check first)

The checks start before you leave home. Most of the risk in buying a second hand guitar sits with who is selling and how they want to be paid, not with the guitar itself. So sort out the seller, the price and your kit first, then spend your time at the inspection on the instrument.

Private seller or business? Your rights are different

The ACCC says most consumer guarantees do not apply to one off sales between two people where the seller is not running a business, including individuals selling through online marketplaces like Gumtree or Facebook Marketplace. When you buy second hand from a business, online or in a shop, the ACCC says you can expect the same consumer guarantee rights as when buying new.

TopicPrivate seller (not a business)Business or dealer
Consumer guaranteesOnly three apply: title to the product, undisturbed possession, and no hidden debts or charges.All the consumer guarantees apply, including acceptable quality, matching the description and fitness for a stated purpose.
If it is faultyNo general right to a refund, repair or replacement for quality. Inspect carefully, because what you see is what you get.A right to a remedy such as a refund, repair or replacement if a guarantee is not met.
What counts as acceptableNot applicable.The ACCC lists factors including the price, the age of the product, whether it was sold new or second hand, and whether the business warned you about defects.

Not sure which you are dealing with? The ACCC’s product safety guidance says the easiest way is to ask the seller whether they are operating as a business. Other clues include a business name with words like Pty Ltd, an ABN, lots of current listings or reviews, and contact details for an office or a sales person. It also suggests keeping the seller’s contact details, the listing and description, and your proof of purchase.

That last point matters for a dealer sale. Disclosed defects count: the ACCC lists whether the business warned you about defects as one of the factors in deciding acceptable quality. Read the listing and the tag, photograph them, and ask the dealer to write any known issues on the receipt so everyone is clear.

Research the price and message the seller

Search the exact model across several listings and note what similar guitars in similar condition are asking. If you search used guitar Facebook Marketplace Australia listings, you will see the same models range widely in price, so condition is where the value is. Then message the seller through the platform and ask: How long have you owned it? Any repairs, cracks or modifications? Does everything work? Can I plug it in? Do you have the receipt or case? A genuine seller usually answers easily.

What to bring

  • A tuner app on your phone, and your phone torch for looking inside an acoustic.
  • For an electric, your own lead and a small amp or headphone amp, so you are not relying on theirs.
  • A strip of paper (to test for a lifting bridge) and a coin or plectrum.
  • The printable inspection card from this post, or this page open on your phone.
  • A friend who plays, if you can. Two sets of eyes see more, and you have company when meeting a stranger.

The inspection card: neck, frets, bridge, electronics, serial

When buying a second hand guitar, do the checks in this order. It takes about 10 minutes, and the order puts the expensive problems first, so you can stop early if the neck is bad.

  1. Neck. Sight down the neck from the headstock end, like aiming along a ruler. Look for a gentle, even dip, not a twist where one edge rises more than the other. Ask if you may check the truss rod; it should turn with steady resistance. If it will not move, or the seller will not let you check, treat it as a warning.
  2. Frets. Look for grooves worn under the strings, especially in the first five frets. Run a finger along the neck edge for sharp fret ends. Play every fret on every string and listen for buzzes or dead notes.
  3. Nut and headstock. Check the open strings are not buzzing or sitting very high. Look closely at the back of the headstock and where it meets the neck for cracks or a glue line from an old break.
  4. Bridge and top (acoustic). Try to slide a strip of paper under the back edge of the bridge. If it goes in, the bridge is lifting. Look along the top for a bulge behind the bridge, and check how much saddle is left above the bridge.
  5. Body and neck joint. Use your torch to look for cracks, inside and out. On a bolt on neck, check for gaps or movement at the joint.
  6. Electronics (electric or electro acoustic). Plug in. Try every pickup position, turn every knob slowly and wiggle the lead in the jack. Crackles are often cheap; silence on one pickup is a workshop job.
  7. Tuners. Tune up and check each tuner turns smoothly and holds. Tune again after you have played for a few minutes.
  8. Serial and history. Photograph the serial number and any labels. A scratched off serial, or a story that changes, is a reason to stop.
  9. Play it. Play the songs you know. If it still feels wrong once you allow for what a setup would fix, it is the wrong guitar for you.

If you live in the Top End, add one more check. Guitars kept in air conditioning can dry out, which often shows up as sharp fret ends, while guitars left in a humid shed can show lifting bridges or swelling. Our guide to guitar care in humid weather explains what to look for and how to look after your new guitar once it is home.

Simple fix, or walk away

This is the column most checklists leave vague. When buying a second hand guitar, a problem only matters if you know what it means for your money. We sort every finding into three groups: a simple fix that a setup or cheap part sorts, a workshop job that needs a quote before you pay, and walk away problems where the repair can be worth more than the guitar.

What you findDecisionWhy
Old or rusty strings, dirty fretboardSimple fixNew strings and a clean
High action, but the truss rod turns and the saddle has roomSimple fixA standard setup
Buzz on a few frets that clears with a little reliefSimple fixA standard setup
Crackly knobs or jack, missing knobs or screws, a slipping tunerSimple fixCleaning or cheap parts
Sharp fret endsWorkshop jobFret end dressing
Deep fret groovesWorkshop jobFret level and crown, or a refret if very worn
Dead pickup or switch positionWorkshop jobCould be a loose wire or a dead pickup
Badly cut nut, small body crack, slightly lifting acoustic bridgeWorkshop jobOften repairable, but needs a repairer’s eye and a quote
Truss rod stuck, stripped or maxed outWalk awayThe neck cannot be adjusted
Twisted neckWalk awayA major repair at best
Headstock or neck joint crack, or a past breakWalk awayUnless a repairer has checked it and the price reflects it
Acoustic top bulging, no saddle left to lowerWalk awayUsually means a neck reset
Serial removed or a story that does not add upWalk awayTitle risk

Two rules make the table useful. First, a guitar that needs a setup is not a bad guitar; almost every used guitar benefits from one, so put the cost of strings and a setup into your budget from the start. Second, workshop jobs are fine if the price leaves room for them. Get a quote from a repairer before you pay, and if the asking price plus the repair is close to a better guitar in good condition, keep looking. We have not listed repair prices because they vary between workshops and regions.

A walk away guitar can still suit a confident hobby repairer who is paying parts money for it. For a first or main guitar, though, the walk away column means exactly what it says.

Try it: the inspection checker

Tick what you found on the guitar and anything the seller has done that worries you. The checker sorts each finding into the three groups above and flags Scamwatch warning signs.

Simple fix or walk away? Inspection checker

Open this on your phone at the inspection. Tick anything you find, then press the button. It sorts each problem into simple fix, workshop job or walk away, and flags Scamwatch warning signs. It is a guide from a teaching studio, not a repairer’s quote.

What you found on the guitar

How the seller is behaving

Facebook Marketplace and scam safety (Scamwatch)

Scamwatch, run by the ACCC, says scammers set up seller accounts on popular marketplaces such as Facebook, Gumtree and eBay, and that the buyers and sellers there are often individuals rather than businesses. A guitar is exactly the kind of item they list: easy to photograph, easy to price low, and wanted by people in a hurry. Here is what Scamwatch advises, applied to buying a second hand guitar.

Scam safety box (based on Scamwatch advice)

  • Inspect before you pay. Scamwatch says not to pay for big ticket items before inspecting the product in person, and to inspect expensive items before making a payment.
  • Use the platform’s recommended payment and keep chats on the platform. Scamwatch advises both.
  • Check the payee. When using PayID or bank transfer, make sure the name matches the person you think you are paying. If it does not, do not pay. Scamwatch warns that many payments are instant and you are unlikely to get your money back.
  • Know the warning signs. An unbelievably low price; being told to pay in unusual ways, such as money order, a preloaded card, or several different PayIDs or accounts; and an account holder who does not match the seller.
  • Be wary of the travelling seller. Scamwatch has warned about fake sellers on classified sites who say they are travelling and someone else will deliver the goods once you have paid.
  • If it goes wrong: contact your bank or card provider immediately, then report it to Scamwatch. IDCARE (1800 595 160) offers free help if your personal details were exposed.

Two habits of our own, on top of the official advice. Meet somewhere you are comfortable, with daylight and other people around, and take a friend. And never let urgency make the decision: a seller who says three other people are coming today is not a reason to skip the neck check. If the guitar is good, it will still be good after ten careful minutes.

If you are buying from a store’s website rather than a person, Scamwatch also suggests checking the ABN on ABN Lookup, looking for terms and conditions, a privacy policy and contact details, and making sure the physical store really exists.

Download the inspection card

The free PDF is a two page card for buying a second hand guitar, to print or save on your phone. Page 1 is the inspection card in the same order as above, with a simple fix or walk away column, tick boxes and space for notes. Page 2 has the seller and scam check, private seller versus business rights from the ACCC, and a quick sum to see whether the asking price still makes sense once you add the cost of the fixes.

Download the free Second Hand Guitar Inspection Card (PDF)

FAQ

Can I get a refund on a guitar from a private seller?

Generally not for quality. The ACCC says most consumer guarantees do not apply to private sales between two people where the seller is not running a business, including sales on Facebook Marketplace and Gumtree. The guarantees of title, undisturbed possession and no hidden debts or charges still apply. That is why buying a second hand guitar privately needs a careful inspection before you pay.

Does a music shop have to give a refund on a used guitar?

The ACCC says businesses must meet the consumer guarantees for second hand products too, so you have a right to a remedy such as a repair, replacement or refund if a guarantee is not met. Acceptable quality takes into account things like price, age, whether it was sold second hand, and any defects the business told you about.

How do I avoid buying a stolen guitar?

Ask how the seller got it and whether they have a receipt, photograph the serial number, and walk away if the serial has been removed or the story keeps changing. The ACCC says private buyers are still guaranteed title to the product, but sorting out a dispute after the fact is far harder than walking away. If you believe a guitar is stolen, contact police.

Should I buy a guitar I cannot play first?

Scamwatch’s advice is not to pay for big ticket items before inspecting them in person. If you cannot see it, there is no inspection card to fill in, and you are relying entirely on the seller.

Is a guitar that needs a setup a bad buy?

No. A setup is normal maintenance, and almost every used guitar benefits from one. Put strings and a setup into your budget. If you like a different string gauge from the one fitted, our guide to string gauge choices explains how gauge and tuning affect the setup.

Which type of guitar should I look for?

Decide that before you start searching, so you are comparing like with like. Our overview of the different kinds of guitars is a good start, and if you are choosing between two classic electrics, read our Stratocaster vs Telecaster comparison. Thinking about bass? See our bass guitar for beginners in Australia guide.

Buy with your eyes open

Buying a second hand guitar goes well when you check the seller first, do the inspection in order, and let the walk away column make the hard calls for you. A setup and new strings will make most good used guitars feel great. Once it is home, if you would like help getting started, we offer guitar lessons in Darwin, and our online beginner course takes you from your first chords at your own pace.

Sources

  • ACCC. Consumer rights and guarantees (private sales, acceptable quality, second hand products). ACCC
  • ACCC Product Safety. Buy safe second hand products online. Product Safety Australia
  • Scamwatch. Buying and selling scams. Scamwatch
  • Scamwatch. ‘Tis the season for online shopping scams (fake sellers on classified sites). Scamwatch

All sources checked on 16 November 2026. This is general information, not legal advice. The repair categories are our teaching studio’s guide, not a repairer’s assessment; always get a quote for workshop jobs.

Image credits

Yamaha FG403S Dreadnought Style Acoustic Guitar (2002), by Housing Works Thrift Shops, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY SA 2.0. Inspection card preview by Maxim’s Guitar Workshop.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *