Log in
MAIL US
inquiry@maximsguitarworkshop.com
CALL US :
+61432184511
Is this song too hard for me guitar: a player working through a song at home on an acoustic guitar

Is This Song Too Hard for Me Yet? Guitar Song Checker

Is this song too hard for me guitar players ask before they start a new song, and it is a fair question. Pick a song that is far beyond you and it turns into weeks of frustration. Pick one that is just a little beyond you and it pulls your playing forward. After 20 years of teaching guitar, we find the honest answer is rarely about the song’s reputation. It is about which skills the song needs and which of those you can already play cleanly. The checker below compares the two for you.

Quick answer

A song is a good fit right now when you can already play every skill it needs cleanly, or when only one or two are close. If it needs two or more skills you cannot do yet, park it for a few weeks. Build the single most basic missing skill first, and play a simpler version of the song meanwhile. Clean means at the song’s speed, without stopping, three times in a row.

Is this song too hard for me on guitar? (quick answer)

Most songs that feel too hard are not hard everywhere. Usually one or two things block you: a barre chord in the chorus, a change that comes too fast, a strumming pattern you cannot keep steady, or singing over the top. The rest of the song is often well within reach.

Here is how to tell if a song is too hard: instead of asking “is this song too hard for me” in general, ask it skill by skill. List what the song needs. Then be honest about each one: can you play it cleanly today, is it getting there, or not yet? That turns a vague worry into a clear plan, and it stops you from giving up on a song you were nearly ready for.

How the song readiness checker works

Next time you wonder “is this song too hard for me”, listen to the song once, or look at a chord chart, and tick each skill it needs. Then choose how you play each of those skills today. The checker gives one of three verdicts:

  • Ready now: you can already play everything the song needs cleanly. Start learning it.
  • Ready with focused work: one skill is missing, or one or two are getting there. This is not a soft yes. Build that one skill on its own for a week or two, then start the song.
  • Park it for later: two or more skills are missing, or several are only half there. Come back in a few weeks.

It also names the one skill to build first, starting with the most basic missing skill, and suggests a simpler version you can play in the meantime. You can save songs to a list on this device, so you can recheck a parked song later. The checker is a guide, not a promise: it cannot hear you play.

Song readiness checker

Tick what the song needs, then say how cleanly you can do each one today. Cleanly means at the song’s speed, without stopping, three times in a row. You get an honest verdict, the one skill to build first and a simpler version to play meanwhile. Saved songs stay on this device only.

My song list

The skills that usually decide the verdict

When students ask us “is this song too hard for me”, the answer almost always comes down to the same handful of skills. They are listed in the checker roughly in the order we would build them:

  • Open chords: the shapes the song uses, each one ringing clearly.
  • Chord changes on time: getting to the next chord on the beat, without a gap. Songs that change chord once or twice a bar are much harder than songs that sit on each chord for a bar or more.
  • The strumming pattern: keeping it steady while the chords change.
  • Barre chords: the classic wall. Songs in keys such as F, B flat or B usually need at least one.
  • Tempo: playing at the speed of the recording, not just slowly.
  • Power chords and palm muting, fingerpicking or a picked riff, bends, and solos: each one is a separate skill, not a bonus.
  • Singing while playing: even easy guitar parts get harder when you add your voice.

Be strict with “clean already”. If you can play the chord but it takes you a second to get there, that is “getting there”, not clean. Guitar song difficulty is mostly about speed and switching, so the change into a chord matters more than the shape on its own.

If you are close: the one skill to build first

A “ready with focused work” verdict means the song is a good goal, but not today. Take the one skill the checker names and practise it on its own for five to ten minutes a day before you touch the song. Keep it to one skill. Spreading practice over five weak spots at once is how songs stay half learned for months.

If barre chords are the blocker, our guide on how to play barre chords has a four week plan. If singing over the guitar is the blocker, work through how to sing and play guitar before you take on the song. When the skill feels clean, run the checker again. If the answer to “is this song too hard for me” is now “ready”, start the song.

If you should park it: a simpler version to play meanwhile

Parking a song is not giving up on it. Write it on your list, and keep playing a simpler version so it stays in your ears and hands:

  • Use a capo with open shapes instead of barre chords, or a smaller shape such as Fmaj7 for F.
  • Play one strum on the first beat of each bar, then add more strums as the changes get easier.
  • Play along with a slowed down track at 70 to 80 percent speed.
  • Strum the chords instead of fingerpicking, and play the chords under the solo instead of the solo itself.
  • Hum or speak the words over a simple strum before you sing them properly.

Meanwhile, pick songs that use the skills you already have. Our list of songs with common chord progressions is a good place to find them, because one progression unlocks many songs. When you ask “is this song too hard for me” about those, the answer is often a happy “ready now”.

Download the free Song Readiness Card (PDF)

The card has the same skill list with tick boxes, so you can check a song away from the screen, plus a parked song list with dates to recheck.

How this sits with learning a song properly

The checker is the gate before the work. Once a song gets a “ready” verdict, our guide on how to learn a song on guitar takes over: map the song, practise the hard parts first, and play it through with the recording.

It also helps to keep expectations realistic. Skills such as clean barre chords or singing while playing take weeks, not days, for most people. Our guide to how long it takes to learn guitar gives typical timelines, so a parked song feels like a plan rather than a failure.

FAQ

How do I tell if a song is too hard for me on guitar?

List the skills the song needs and check each one against what you can play cleanly today. One missing skill means focused work first, so the honest answer to “is this song too hard for me” is “not for long”. Two or more missing skills usually means park it for now and build the basics.

Should I learn songs that are a bit too hard?

A song that is slightly beyond you, with one skill to build, is a great goal. A song that needs several new skills at once tends to cause frustration, so build those skills first or play a simpler version.

Is this song too hard for me guitar wise if I can play the chords slowly?

Not necessarily. Slow and clean is the right start. Count it as “getting there” until you can change chords at the song’s speed, then use a metronome to close the gap.

How long should I wait before trying a parked song again?

Recheck it every few weeks, or as soon as the skill the checker named feels clean. Saved songs stay in your list on this device, so you can run them again later.

Does the checker know how hard a famous song is?

No. It does not rate songs. It compares what one song needs with what you can do, so the same song can be “ready now” for one player and “park it” for another.

Every guitarist has a song or two parked for later, and getting back to them is one of the best feelings in learning. If the checker keeps pointing to the basics, such as open chords, changes and strumming, our online beginner course builds them in order. Otherwise, start with the song map in how to learn a song on guitar.

Featured image: “Lonely senior man playing an accoustic guitar at home” by Shixart1985, Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY 2.0.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *